FEDERAL BUDGET 2014
February 11, 2014
On February 11, 2014, the Federal Minister of Finance, Jim Flaherty, presented the majority government’s budget. The budget does not change corporate or personal tax rates. The following insight discusses the tax initiatives proposed in the budget:
Canada has an extensive network of bilateral tax treaties with other countries that support cross-border trade and investment. In the March 21, 2013 federal budget, the government announced that in response to ‘treaty shopping’ concerns, it would consult on possible measures that would ‘protect the integrity of Canada’s tax treaties while preserving a business tax environment that is conducive to foreign investment.’
According to the 2013 budget documents, ‘treaty shopping’ involves situations when a resident of a foreign country that is not a party to a particular Canadian tax treaty enjoys benefits under that treaty. Historically, the Canadian government has largely been unsuccessful in challenging treaty shopping cases in the courts.
Further to the budget announcement, on August 12, 2013, the Department of Finance (Finance) released a consultation paper Treaty Shopping – The Problem and Possible Solutions to aid in examining the range of possible approaches to address the practice of treaty shopping in Canada.
In the consultation paper, Finance provides additional commentary and background on treaty shopping in the Canadian context, including its views on the hallmarks of treaty shopping. Finance also invited interested parties to respond to seven specific questions by December 13, 2013, which in essence explored whether:
The BEPS calendar dated January 30, 2014 notes that a discussion draft on tax treaty abuse is expected to be released by the OECD in March 2014, with comments due within 30 days after publication of the discussion draft.
The budget sets out the main elements of this proposed rule, for discussion:
Consultation on Tax Planning by Multinational Enterprises
Due to the government’s commitment to ensure tax fairness and protect the Canadian tax base, input is invited on:
Comments must be submitted before June 12, 2014.
An anti-avoidance rule in the foreign accrual property income (FAPI) regime is intended to prevent Canadian taxpayers, e.g. financial institutions, from shifting income from the insurance of Canadian risks (i.e. risks in respect of persons resident in Canada, property situated in Canada or businesses carried on in Canada) offshore.
The anti-avoidance rule will be amended relating to the insurance of Canadian risks. For taxation years beginning after February 10, 2014, clarifications will ensure the rule applies when:
Offshore Regulated Banks
The budget amends the exception from the FAPI regime for regulated foreign financial institutions by requiring the following conditions to be met for this exception to apply:
Interest on obligations owing to non-arm’s length non-resident persons can be subject to Part XIII withholding tax, subject to certain exceptions under a tax treaty, and deductions for such interest can be limited by the thin capitalization rules. Certain back-to-back loan arrangements have been undertaken by taxpayers with an unrelated third party to avoid the application of these existing rules. The budget introduces a new anti-avoidance rule in respect of withholding tax on interest payments, and amends an existing avoidance measure in the thin capitalization rules, to address these back-to-back loan arrangements.
In both cases, the new rule will apply to arrangements when:
Related amounts of interest will also be deemed to have been paid or payable to the non-resident person for thin capitalization purposes, and for Part XIII purposes to the extent that tax under that Part would otherwise be reduced by virtue of the arrangement.
The new anti-avoidance rules will apply, for the thin capitalization rules, to taxation years that begin after 2014 and, for Part XIII withholding tax, to amounts paid or credited after 2014.
Update on Automatic Exchange of Information for Tax Purposes
The US Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA), enacted in 2010, would require non-US financial institutions, starting July 1, 2014, to:
Under the IGA, Canadian financial institutions will report to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) information in respect of US persons that will be transmitted by the CRA to the IRS under the Canada-US tax treaty and be subject to its confidentiality safeguards.
Reporting exemptions apply to, among other things:
The CRA will not collect the US tax liability of a Canadian citizen if the individual was a Canadian citizen at the time the liability arose (whether or not the individual was also a US citizen at that time).
This new reporting regime will come into effect starting in July 2014, with Canada and the US beginning to receive enhanced tax information from each other in 2015.
Update on Tax Treaties and Tax Information Exchange Agreements
Canada continues to actively negotiate and conclude tax treaties to reduce tax barriers to international trade and investment, combat international tax evasion and aggressive tax avoidance, strengthen Canada’s bilateral economic relationships, and create enhanced opportunities for Canadian businesses abroad.
Canada now has 92 tax treaties in force, three tax treaties signed but not yet in force, and eight tax treaties and protocols under negotiation.
Canada has brought into force 18 Tax Information Exchange Agreements (TIEAs), signed four TIEAs that are not yet in force and is negotiating TIEAs with eight other jurisdictions.
Tax Incentives for Clean Energy Generation
The capital cost allowance (CCA) system provides accelerated CCA deductions under Class 43.1 (30%) and Class 43.2 (50%) on a declining-balance basis for certain clean energy generation and energy conservation equipment acquired before 2020.
The budget expands Class 43.2 by making certain water-current energy equipment and gasification equipment eligible for inclusion. These measures apply to equipment acquired after February 10, 2014, that had not previously been used or acquired for use.
Consultation on Eligible Capital PropertyThe budget announces a public consultation to repeal the eligible capital property (ECP) regime, replace it with a new capital cost allowance (CCA) class available to businesses and transfer taxpayers’ existing cumulative eligible capital (CEC) pools to the new CCA class. Detailed draft legislative proposals will be released for comment and the timing of the implementation will be determined after the consultation.
The proposed rules include:
Personal Tax Measures
Tax on Split Income
The ‘tax on split income’ limits income-splitting techniques that seek to shift certain types of income from a higher-income individual to a lower-income minor.
To maintain the integrity of the tax on split income, commencing the 2014 taxation year, the definition ‘split income’ will include income that is, directly or indirectly, paid or allocated to a minor from a trust or partnership, if:
The 2013 budget announced the intention to consult on the potential elimination of graduated rates for testamentary trusts, certain estates, and grandfathered inter vivos trusts. The budget proposes to generally proceed with these measures. Specifically, the budget proposes to apply flat top- rate taxation to the above trusts and estates and make certain consequential changes. One exception to this proposal is that graduated rates will still apply for the first 36 months of an estate that arises as a consequence of an individual’s death and that is a testamentary trust. Another exception is for testamentary trusts for the benefit of disabled individuals.
Further proposed changes will ensure such trusts (except for the first 36 months of an estate) no longer benefit from special treatment under certain rules including:
The budget proposes for the 2016 and subsequent taxation years to provide more flexibility in the tax treatment of charitable donations made in the context of a death that occurs after 2015. Donations made by a will, and those made by designation under a Registered Retirement Savings Plan, Registered Retirement Income Fund, Tax-Free Savings Account or life insurance policy, will no longer be deemed to be made by the individual immediately before the individual’s death. Instead, these donations will be deemed to have been made by the individual’s estate at the time the property is transferred to a qualified donee, provided the transfer occurs within 36 months after death. In addition, the trustee of the individual’s estate will have the flexibility to allocate the available donation among: the taxation year of the estate in which the donation is made; an earlier taxation year of the estate; or the last two taxation years of the individual. The current annual credit limits will continue to apply.
An exemption for ‘immigration trusts’ from the non-resident rules applies where the contributors to the trust are individuals each of whom is resident in Canada for a total period of not more than 60 months (i.e. newly resident Canadians).
The budget proposes to eliminate the 60-month exemption for immigration trusts, including related rules, for taxation years:
Adoptive parents can claim a 15% non-refundable tax credit on eligible adoption expenses. The budget increases the maximum amount of such expenses for 2014 to $15,000 per child. The maximum will be indexed to inflation for subsequent years.
Medical Expense Tax Credit
The budget expands the list of expenses eligible for the Medical Expense Tax Credit to include, for amounts incurred after 2013:
The budget introduces a $450 non-refundable tax credit, beginning in 2014, for certain search and rescue volunteers who provide at least 200 hours of services in a year. An individual who claims this new credit cannot also claim the existing volunteer firefighters tax credit, and claiming either credit will make the individual ineligible for the existing tax exemption of up to $1,000 for honoraria received for volunteer efforts.
Mineral Exploration Tax Credit
The mineral exploration tax credit is extended by one year to flow-through share agreements entered into before April 1, 2015.
Farming and Fishing Businesses
The budget proposes, for dispositions and transfers that occur after the 2013 taxation year, to extend eligibility for the intergenerational rollover of farming and fishing property and the lifetime capital gains exemption to:
The budget proposes, starting 2014 taxation years, to extend the tax deferral for farmers who dispose of breeding livestock due to drought, flood or excess moisture conditions existing in prescribed regions, to disposals of bees, and horses that are over 12 months of age, that are kept for breeding.
Amateur Athlete Trusts
The budget proposes to allow income contributed to an amateur athlete trust after 2013 to qualify as earned income for purposes of determining the registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) contribution limit of the trust’s beneficiary.
If an individual who contributed to an amateur athlete trust before 2014 makes an election in writing and submits it to the CRA before March 3, 2015, any contributions made in 2011, 2012 and 2013 will also qualify as earned income. The individual’s RRSP limit will be re-determined for each of these years and any additional RRSP room will be added to the individual’s RRSP contribution room for 2014.
Pension Transfer Limits
In 2011, a special rule was introduced in certain situations allowing a member leaving a defined benefit registered pension plan (RPP) whose estimated pension benefit was reduced due to plan underfunding to disregard that benefit reduction in calculating the portion of a lump-sum commutation payment from the RPP that may be transferred to an RRSP on a tax-free basis (i.e. the transferable amount). If the rule applies, the maximum transferable amount for a plan member who leaves an underfunded RPP will be the same as if the RPP were fully funded.
The budget proposes to extend this rule to commutation payments made after 2012, to a plan member who leaves an RPP if that payment has been reduced due to plan underfunding and either:
GST/HST Credit Administration
The budget proposes to eliminate the need for an individual to apply for the GST/HST credit on their annual income tax returns and to allow the CRA to automatically determine if an individual is eligible to receive the GST/HST credit. This measure applies starting with income tax returns for the 2014 taxation year.
Charities and Non-Profit Organizations
Reducing Administrative Burden on Charities
The CRA will be provided with funding, over five years, to modernize its information technology, to enable charities to apply for registration and file their annual information returns electronically. Charities will also be allowed to conduct aspects of charitable lotteries by computer, to reduce administration costs.
Donations of Ecologically Sensitive Land
For donations of ecologically sensitive land, or easements, covenants and servitudes on such land made after February 10, 2014, the carry-forward period will be extended to ten years.
Donations of Certified Cultural Property
Previously, gifts of certified cultural property were measured at fair market value for the purpose of donation tax credits. The budget introduces a rule limiting the value of such a gift to its cost amount to the donor if the property was acquired as part of a tax shelter gifting arrangement. This restriction applies to gifts made after February 10, 2014.
State Supporters of Terrorism
The budget provides that if a charity or amateur athletic association accepts a donation after February 10, 2014, from a state (or agency thereof) that is considered to be a supporter of terrorism under the State Immunity Act, the Minister of National Revenue may refuse to register the organization, or revoke its registration.
Consultation on Non-Profit Organizations
The budget announces that the government plans to review whether the income tax exemption and related reporting requirements for non-profit organizations remain properly targeted and provide sufficient transparency and accountability. A consultation paper will be released for public comment.
Sales and Excise Tax Measures
Application of the GST/HST to the Health Care Sector
The budget proposes three changes to improve the application of the Goods and Services Tax/Harmonized Sales Tax (GST/HST) to certain health-related services and medical and assistive devices. For supplies made after February 11, 2014:
Under the GST/HST, a group relief election, generally referred to as the ‘nil consideration election,’ is available allowing registrants that are resident in Canada, engaged exclusively in commercial activities and members of a closely related group to not account for tax on certain transactions between them.
Effective January 1, 2015:
Joint Ventures and GST/HST
Participants in certain joint ventures can make a joint venture election that simplifies the GST/HST accounting obligations in respect of their joint venture activities.
To allow more commercial joint venture activities and participants access to the GST/HST simplification benefits available under the joint venture election, the government will propose new joint venture election measures, as well as complementary anti-avoidance measures, that will allow the joint venture participants to make the election as long as the joint venture’s activities are exclusively commercial and the participants are engaged exclusively in commercial activities.
Strengthening Compliance with GST/HST Registration
To strengthen GST/HST compliance and help the CRA combat the underground economy, the Minister of National Revenue will be given the discretionary authority to register and assign a GST/HST registration number when a person fails to comply with the requirement to register, even after having been notified of the requirement to register by the CRA.
This measure will apply on royal assent to the enacting legislation.
Starting February 12, 2014, the rate of excise duty on cigarettes and on other tobacco products will increase to account for inflation since 2002.
In addition, starting February 12, 2014, the ‘duty free’ rate for cigarettes will increase and, going forward, will be legislatively linked to changes in the excise duty.
The excise duty rates on tobacco products, including the ‘duty free’ rates, will be indexed to the Consumer Price Index and automatically adjusted every five years, starting December 1, 2019.
To ensure that the rate changes are applied consistently to all cigarettes, inventories of cigarettes held by manufacturers, importers, wholesalers and retailers at the end of February 11, 2014, will be subject to a per cigarette tax.
An inventory tax on cigarettes will also apply at the time of each five-year inflationary excise duty adjustment.
Standardizing Sanctions Related to False Statements in Excise Tax Returns
A new administrative monetary penalty will apply, and the existing criminal offence will be amended, for the making of false statements or omissions in an excise tax return and related offences under the non-GST/HST portion of the Excise Tax Act.
The new administrative monetary penalty will be the greater of $250 and 25% of the tax avoided.
For the revised criminal offence:
Other Tax Measures
Aboriginal Tax Policy
Canada supports initiatives that encourage the exercise of direct taxation powers by Aboriginal governments, and reiterates its willingness to discuss and put into effect direct taxation arrangements with interested Aboriginal governments.
Customs Tariff Measures
The Customs Tariff will be amended to make the Governor General subject to the same tariff rules as other government office holders. Consequential amendments to the GST/HST importation rules will also be proposed.
Supporting Offshore Oil and Gas Development
The 20% Most-Favoured-Nation rate of duty on imported mobile offshore drilling units (MODUs) will be eliminated in respect of goods imported into Canada after May 4, 2014.
Previously Announced Measures
The budget confirms that the government will proceed with the following previously announced measures: